Three Words from an Ohio State Legend in Response to Jeremiah Smith’s WR Mount Rushmore

Jeremiah Smith is a name that’s already making headlines in college football, and he hasn’t even played a full season yet. As one of the most hyped wide receiver recruits in recent history, the Ohio State freshman is already turning heads with his talent, confidence, and personality. Recently, he stirred up the football world again by naming his personal “Wide Receiver Mount Rushmore.” That is, his top four wide receivers of all time.

It was a moment meant to be fun and show respect to the legends of the game. But the reaction from one Ohio State great caught fans by surprise. With just three words, this Buckeye legend responded to Jeremiah Smith’s list — and those three words have sparked a conversation that’s still going strong across social media and sports radio.

Let’s take a closer look at what happened, why it matters, and how it shows the unique bond between past and present Buckeye greats.

Jeremiah Smith’s WR Mount Rushmore included four names that clearly meant a lot to him. Whether it was based on talent, influence, or personal preference, Smith stood confidently behind his list. As expected, the list included some of the biggest names in the football world. But what caught attention wasn’t just who was on the list  it was who wasn’t.

Surprisingly, one of Ohio State’s most accomplished wide receivers wasn’t named by Smith. Fans quickly noticed that this legend  someone who had helped put the Buckeyes on the map during his time — didn’t make the cut. That legend, whose name still rings loud in Ohio Stadium, decided to respond.

But instead of a long explanation or angry comment, the Buckeye legend replied with just three words: “That’s your four.” It was simple. It was respectful. But it carried weight.

Those three words have become more than just a comment. They’ve become a symbol of how college football has changed, how generations communicate, and how greatness is defined by different people in different ways.

When fans saw the response, it sparked discussions. Some thought the legend deserved to be on every wide receiver Mount Rushmore, especially one created by an Ohio State player. Others defended Jeremiah Smith’s right to make his own choices and said his list was just a reflection of his era  what he grew up watching, what inspired him, and who shaped his game.

Jeremiah Smith himself didn’t respond with anger or defensiveness. Instead, he made it clear that he respects every legend who’s come before him. He even said he hopes to earn his own spot on someone’s Mount Rushmore someday. That kind of humility from a young player shows why Ohio State fans are so excited about him. He’s confident, but he’s also aware of the tradition and greatness of the program he now represents.

The legend’s response  “That’s your four”  wasn’t meant to insult or dismiss. In fact, it showed a level of wisdom and understanding. It said, “I might not agree with your list, but I respect your right to have it.” That type of response is rare in the world of sports today, where arguments and drama are often louder than mutual respect.

But let’s not forget who this Ohio State legend is. During his time in Columbus, he was unstoppable. He set records, won awards, and made plays that are still shown on highlight reels today. He helped Ohio State win big games and became a fan favorite not just for what he did on the field, but for how he carried himself off it. Many fans believe he helped shape what Ohio State’s wide receiver room looks like today.

Some even say that without players like him, recruits like Jeremiah Smith might not have picked Ohio State at all. The success of the wide receiver program didn’t happen overnight. It was built by legends who set the standard and passed it down to the next generation. That’s what makes the interaction between Smith and the legend so powerful. It’s not just about football  it’s about respect, legacy, and learning from those who came before.

This moment also highlights the importance of generational influence in sports. Every player grows up watching different stars. For Jeremiah Smith, his Mount Rushmore might include players who dominated during his childhood  NFL stars who inspired him to chase greatness. For the legend, his view of greatness was shaped by a different era. And that’s okay. In fact, it’s what makes the game special.

Some fans believe this is a teaching moment, not just for Smith, but for all young players. It’s a reminder to always study the history of the game and appreciate the shoulders you stand on. That’s not to say your opinion is wrong, but that it can always grow. The same way Smith wants to earn respect, he can also give it to those who paved the way.

The “That’s your four” comment also highlights the culture of Ohio State’s wide receiver room. It’s a place full of competition, pride, and unity. The greats push the young guys, and the young guys work hard to live up to the standard. Players like Chris Olave, Garrett Wilson, Jaxon Smith-Njigba, Marvin Harrison Jr., and now Jeremiah Smith are all part of that pipeline. Each one brings something different, but they all wear the same jersey and play for the same program.

Coach Brian Hartline, who played at Ohio State and now coaches the wide receivers, has helped build this environment. He teaches his players to honor the past, own the present, and prepare for the future. He’s likely seen this whole exchange and smiled, knowing it’s exactly the kind of respectful fire that drives his players to be great.

The truth is, both the legend and Jeremiah Smith are right in their own way. Smith has the right to name his top four, and the legend has the right to respond with wisdom and pride. Neither side is wrong. In fact, their interaction shows that greatness recognizes greatness  even when it’s not on the same list.

As the 2025 season approaches, all eyes will be on Jeremiah Smith. Not just because he’s a top recruit, but because he’s now part of the conversation. He’s no longer just a fan of the game  he’s in it. He’ll have the chance to make plays, break records, and maybe even earn a spot on someone else’s Mount Rushmore in the future.

And somewhere, that legend who responded with three words will be watching. Maybe from the stands, maybe from his home, or maybe on the sidelines. But he’ll be watching   not with anger, but with pride. Because he knows what it takes to be great at Ohio State. He knows how hard the journey is. And he knows that one day, Jeremiah Smith might inspire the next young receiver to dream big and aim high.

In the end, the story of “That’s your four” is not about disagreement. It’s about connection. It’s about passing the torch. It’s about remembering that while everyone’s list may look different, the respect for the game and for each other is what makes college football so powerful.

Jeremiah Smith’s Mount Rushmore was just the beginning of the story. Now, it’s up to him to show why he belongs in the conversation. And if he does, maybe one day he’ll be the one replying to a younger player’s list  with the same grace, class, and unforgettable words.